Cathy Benedict, Ed.D
  • Home
  • Education
  • TC - NYC
    • 4005 Principles & Teaching
    • The Teacher
    • Masters Project
    • 4002 Curriculum Theory and History
    • Min it to win it - 3 minute thesis
  • Presentations
  • Publications
  • Western / FIU / NYU
    • Western >
      • The Teacher
      • Kodály Based Musicianship >
        • 2020-2021
        • 2019-2020
        • 2018-2019
        • 2017-2018
      • Music Education in Inclusive Contexts
      • Undergrad Research
      • Elementary Music 2022 >
        • Elementary Music 2020
      • Study Hall
      • Grad photos
      • MESA Students
      • Study Abroad
      • Research in Music Education
      • Curriculum and Policy 2022
      • Theories Of Music Education
      • Intro to Music Ed >
        • Fall 2019
        • Fall 2021
        • Fall 2018
        • Winter 2018
        • Fall 2017
        • Winter 2017
        • Fall 2015
        • Winter 2016
        • Fall 2016
  • Guest Teaching
  • Western Kodály Levels
    • Summer 2022
    • Summer 2019
    • Summer 2018
    • Summer 2017 >
      • Kodaly videos etc
    • Summer 2016
    • Photos from Kodaly club
    • IKS Alberta 2017
  • New Horizons Band
  • United Nations Project
  • Blog
  • Allsup Book Launch
  • MLAL
General Educators Teaching Music: 
It’s Not About Music, It’s About Pedagogical Possibilities

Cathy Benedict, Ed.D  FIU

The discipline of music education is an integral part of many public schools.  Indeed, most of the top-rated high schools in the US have thriving, robust music programs as part of their curriculum.  Unfortunately, an education in and through music is either absent or presents itself as a lessened presence in the lives of many young students.  Further, many school districts (particularly in urban centers) have eliminated requirements for music in pre-1st grade, leading to an absence of any specialized music teaching at that level.

The consequence of such political and economic decisions often means that the responsibility for the inclusion of music in early grades falls into the hands of general educators.  As such many, if not most, College of Education preservice students are mandated to take a course designed to prepare them to teach and integrate music/arts in younger grades.  As we know, these pre-service teachers are under tremendous accountability pressure to “teach” their students and “measure” their learning.  Nothing can be left to chance:  behavioral objectives are their constant companion as are detailed articulations of the expectations and goals of every single lesson (most of which is required to be stated on the board).

Regardless of the fact that nationwide thousands of preservice students per year take this course little research exists as to the ways in which they may enact learned pedagogical practices or the extent of the impact of such instruction upon preservice teachers and their perceptions and dispositions toward educating in and through music.  (Campbell & Burdell, 1996; Wiggins & Wiggins, 2008).  Further still, information regarding how and if preservice teachers do carry said perceptions, dispositions and practices over into their first years of teaching is lacking.

A better understanding of how and in what ways preservice teachers consider, embrace and enact pedagogical strategies that veer from the traditional norm of their education classes can generate benefits to future preservice teachers and the students with whom they will interact within schools.  Further, music educators, particularly those teaching in elementary settings, have much to gain from better understanding how to mindfully integrate their work with that of the day-to-day planning and actions of general educators.  This paper/presentation offers preliminary results from conversations with and observations of early career general educators who have undertaken just such a required course during which neither “teaching to” the standards, nor “students will be able to” (SWBAT) ever entered the educative discourse.

Campbell, M. & Burdell, P. ( Fall 1996). Conceptions of Knowledge and Teaching Practice among Music Education Students and Elementary Education Students. McGill Journal of Education, 31, (3) pp. 231-45.

Wiggins, J. & Wiggins, R. (2008). Primary Music Education in the Absence of Specialists. International Journal of Education & the Arts, 9, (12), pp. 1-26.

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.